Alfa Romeo Giulia Forum banner

Please Alfa, don't fake the engine sound

24K views 34 replies 21 participants last post by  Tomson  
#1 ·
I did some forum searching, and I'm pretty sure that Giulias do not have that most appalling of new car "features" -- fake engine sound (I really hope I'm right about this). However, I was very disappointed to learn that, apparently, Stelvios do fake the engine sound. I'm amazed and saddened that Alfa would engage in this engine sound fraud. Further, it is expected that this will infest Giulias at some point also. (Does anyone know when?) To each his own, but for me, fake engine sound is reprehensible. It could be the best sound on the planet, and it would still be reprehensible. As I understand it, the Stelvio's fake sound is based on the intake sounds picked up by the microphone, then manipulated by a computer and played through a speaker, rather than being a recording played through the speakers as it is in BMWs. Regardless, any "engine sound" played through a car's speaker(s) is unforgivable. Engine sound is a big part of the enjoyment of a car for me, but only if it's real.

So, having seen the picture of the manifold-mounted microphone used in the Stelvio, I looked at my car and -- huge relief -- it isn't there.

IMO, fake engine sound is inexcusable, especially in an enthusiast car like an Alfa Romeo, a company long known for its engines. It's an absolute deal-breaker for me -- it's why I ruled out a new BMW or Audi. I understand that it's harder to make a car with a turbocharger sitting in the exhaust sound good, but the Giulia is proof that it can be done at least reasonably well.

Please Alfa, DON'T FAKE THE ENGINE SOUND!
 
#2 ·
Stelvio has some kind of microphone next to the intake, the signal from which is used to generate some sound in the interior. It is not clear to me if the sound is just amplified and filtered, or if it is synthesized.
 
#9 · (Edited)
Actually, it is an 'free' option that you can choose in the car configurator on the (European) Alfa Romeo website.

I ordered mine at the dealer in the last week of December 2017 and we went through all options double-checking things before confirming the order with Alfa Romeo. And I'm pretty sure it wasn't an option available in the car configurator tool then, so was a January 2018 addition (along with the new price list for 2018).

Thankfully, the "Engine Sound Enhancement" isn't added by default.

-krish
 
#8 ·
If I remember right, Back in 2009 or so the Ford Mustangs had a speaker just for enhancement.
 
#13 ·
I think there was also a resonator in the driver's side A-pillar.

The question is: what codes will it generate if you cut the microphone wire?
Maybe it deactivates the traction and stability control.
 
owns 2020 Alfa Romeo Giulia Ti Sport AWD
#23 ·
My car was built in Sept 2017 (MY2018 Ti Q4 sport) and definitely does not have the microphone.
Some while ago MacGeek posted a picture of the microphone. It is fairly large and relatively easy to spot if you know what it looks like. He also said that Giulia would (likely?) eventually have this equipment.

My wiring diagram shows the microphone connected to a dedicated device for this sound generation. It is said to take the microphone input and process it to produce the result, with no clear definition of "process it". Perhaps have a helper made some random noises under the hood of a running Stelvio and see if those random noises appear on the audio in the cabin? If the signal is just being amplified wouldn't the microphone be simply connected to the AUX input of the audio system?

There are noisy things that can be heard under the hood other than the engine that one might not want to hear, such as the cooling fan, precipitation or the motorcycle in front of you. Simply amplifying the engine sound picked up by a microphone has the potential to result in obnoxious sounds in the cabin.
 
#16 ·
Fake engine sound be like
 
owns 2020 Alfa Romeo Giulia Ti Sport AWD
#19 ·
Hawkeye_a My car is also a 2018 Ti Sport, and I’m nearly sure it doesn’t have it. That the Giulia doesn’t fake its engine sound is also a major reason I bought it. Fake engine sound offends every cell in my body. It’s a complete deal-breaker for me — it simply obliterates any interest I’d otherwise have in a car.
 
#20 ·
Tbh its not completely unexpected that almost everyone is going this way. As tech advances keep coming the cabin gets quieter and quieter. Its just a way to compensate for that for this that want to "feel" the ride. It will also appease those who like quiet rides. Pretty much all cars will go this route so you will learn to adjust accordingly. Specially in the hybrid/electric future.
 
#21 ·
But isn't that the way the world is going now though? Fake everything... fake white teeth, fake hair (extensions), fake boobs, fake butts (implants), fake faces (totally covered in make-up), fake news, fake "reality" shows, fake lifestyle (selfies)... you name it. We've got an entire generation that lives in a world of non-stop fake. They're even trying to push AR "augmented reality" so you can superimpose fake on top of reality.

Who knows... maybe the "Matrix" wasn't so far-fetched after all. There are probably people who would sign-up for a deal like that if it was actually available. We live in strange times, and they seem to be getting stranger by the year.

One of the things I love about my Ti Lusso is REAL Italian leather, and REAL walnut accents. I absolutely do NOT want fake engine sounds. I was listening to the sound of a 1995 Ferrari 412 T2 last night; a real 3.0L V12. Glorious:


There's just no substitute for the real deal.
 
#24 ·
Oh. My. GOD! That's just beautiful. What a howl~ I love it!
GReg
But isn't that the way the world is going now though? Fake everything... fake white teeth, fake hair (extensions), fake boobs, fake butts (implants), fake faces (totally covered in make-up), fake news, fake "reality" shows, fake lifestyle (selfies)... you name it. We've got an entire generation that lives in a world of non-stop fake. They're even trying to push AR "augmented reality" so you can superimpose fake on top of reality.

Who knows... maybe the "Matrix" wasn't so far-fetched after all. There are probably people who would sign-up for a deal like that if it was actually available. We live in strange times, and they seem to be getting stranger by the year.

One of the things I love about my Ti Lusso is REAL Italian leather, and REAL walnut accents. I absolutely do NOT want fake engine sounds. I was listening to the sound of a 1995 Ferrari 412 T2 last night; a real 3.0L V12. Glorious:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SoZiTxdQyw

There's just no substitute for the real deal.
 
#25 · (Edited)
Revoze, I guarantee you that I will NOT “adjust” to fake engine sound. I will not buy a car that fakes its engine sound. Period. I simply won’t want one. It turns me off entirely. It would turn something that adds to my enjoyment of a car into something that I would actively despise — it would utterly ruin the driving experience for me. If all new cars fake the sound, I’ll just buy old cars.
 
#29 ·
Very thankful the Giulia does not have a microphone. As relatively "sedate" as its engine (2.0L) sounds, it still has those sexy purrs and howls in D mode during up and downshifts.
 
#30 ·
The car has good sound insulation, so opening windows and/or sunroof is the best way (short of exhaust system upgrades) to enjoy its music.
 
owns 2020 Alfa Romeo Giulia Ti Sport AWD
#31 ·
Instead of "fake noise" they should have a setting to hear the un muffled sound (like in race mode on the QV), all the time.... kindof like the suspension setting on the DNA selector (QV and Q2 models, i think).

Ive seen many reviewers complain about windnoise. And while i like the sound of my TiSportQ2, i would have liked to hear more of the REAL(not through speakers) engine noise.
 
#32 ·
IMO, wind noise in Giulia is fake news. There is some road noise, but if you get on some new pavement (reference US-395 just south of Walker in the West Walker River Canyon) the car becomes unsettlingly quiet with no sense of speed at all. Even in a strong cross wind the only indication that I got of the wind was the car jerking sideways and of course trees next to the road bending.

Maybe with the windows down the wind noise is higher than other cars, I do not drive that way. Maybe there is some wind noise associated with a sunroof, I would not know.
 
#35 ·
Hi guys

I'm newbie here. I just bought Giulia Veloce from 2018 and I noticed in equipment list that I have this famous engine sound enhancement system, so I started to dig in about that and I joined here. I can see also that both Veloce and Ti versions (in Europe) have it by default...

Do you know if there is a way to deactivate it and no side effects occurs?