Alfa Romeo Giulia Forum banner
21 - 29 of 29 Posts
Performance difference on the track is based on the entire weight of the wheel including tires, where the weight is (bigger wheels moves the weight out away from the center), and tire width. Beyond that it's an issue of which tires you're using as far as cornering performance.

If you look at pictures of the wheels and tires used by the guys who go fast professionally, you'll notice they tend to use the smallest wheels they can fit around the brakes, with tall sidewall tires. I've attached two pics showing a Formula 1 wheel and a NASCAR wheel.

Unsprung rotating weight exacts a penalty in the amount of power it takes to get it moving and slow it down. The farther from the rotation center the weight is, the greater the penalty. Even if a tire is heavy, it's filled with air compared to a big wheel where the majority of the weight tends to be the farthest from the center.

Smallest wheel with tall sidewall tires may not look impressive to the show-car/parking lot crowd, but out on the track they rule.
Eagle's post is technically correct, although I would like to add a couple points. In F1 (not sure about nascar) the wheel size is dictated by the rules of the Formula. There are several reasons for that, but one benefit is there is enough sidewall for advertising space. I am not sure if that's one of the reasons for the rule, but it makes sense to me.

Greg
 
There are some oddities regarding car tires and wheels that I hope someone can explain.

1) Aluminum has a much higher strength to weight ratio than rubber, so why does a wheel assembly with less aluminum and more rubber weigh less? Do not say the air is carrying the weight, because that is not true*.

2) Bicycle and motorcycle tire cross section forms a circle when inflated dictated by the physics of pneumatic inflation, but car tires do not seem to behave this way. Stiff parts in the car tire? Thick parts in the car tire? The profile of bicycle tires is fixed, for example.

3) What ever happened to wire wheels? They work really well for bicycles and save significant weight compared to any other type of wheel. Offsets too large? Cars transitioned to cast alloy wheels before Jobst Brandt published his treatise on how to make a reliable and light weight wire wheel, then never looked back?

4) In the Nascar tire picture above, the wheel offset looks so extreme that the brakes don't appear to be inside the wheel barrel. If smaller wheels are better, why isn't geometry like that used elsewhere?

* The sidewalls of the tire are preloaded by the air. When a load is added to the tire the tension in the tire sidewalls decreases, creating the force to carry weight. Thus, the tire can only carry as much weight as the pre-tension in the sidewalls of the tires and the limit of that pre-tension is largely a function of the strength of the rubber in the sidewall.
 
There are some oddities regarding car tires and wheels that I hope someone can explain.

1) Aluminum has a much higher strength to weight ratio than rubber, so why does a wheel assembly with less aluminum and more rubber weigh less? Do not say the air is carrying the weight, because that is not true*.

2) Bicycle and motorcycle tire cross section forms a circle when inflated dictated by the physics of pneumatic inflation, but car tires do not seem to behave this way. Stiff parts in the car tire? Thick parts in the car tire? The profile of bicycle tires is fixed, for example.

3) What ever happened to wire wheels? They work really well for bicycles and save significant weight compared to any other type of wheel. Offsets too large? Cars transitioned to cast alloy wheels before Jobst Brandt published his treatise on how to make a reliable and light weight wire wheel, then never looked back?

4) In the Nascar tire picture above, the wheel offset looks so extreme that the brakes don't appear to be inside the wheel barrel. If smaller wheels are better, why isn't geometry like that used elsewhere?

* The sidewalls of the tire are preloaded by the air. When a load is added to the tire the tension in the tire sidewalls decreases, creating the force to carry weight. Thus, the tire can only carry as much weight as the pre-tension in the sidewalls of the tires and the limit of that pre-tension is largely a function of the strength of the rubber in the sidewall.
1) Automotive tires aren't just rubber, they're actually a cross mesh weave of high performance fabrics that are encased in rubber, which is what you see when the tire wears 'down to the threads'. The fabrics are generally lighter than rubber, and tires of course are hollowed out as opposed to metal wheels which are solid, so as a result tires for their size weigh less than metal wheels.

2) Automotive tires have to handle load weights of thousands of pounds, so they are designed with a completely different sidewall structure than bike tires. The sidewalls in fact serve somewhat like shock absorbers in helping to control the shifting weight while cornering, and also help smooth out vertical transitions.

3) My second car was a 1968 Triumph Spitfire with wire wheels, and while they looked great, they were a total PITA to clean and keep tuned. My guess is they fell out of fashion for those reasons, as well as it was considered a 'dated' look. During the 60's and after, everything was about being modern and futuristic; wire wheels weren't it.

4) Nascar wheels are very wide so even with the offset there's still a lot of wheel barrel in there. As in all the pro racing sports, the teams always go with as much wheel as the rules will allow. I know that inboard brakes have been used in Formula 1, but that may have issues with cooling, not to mention the space required if those were used on a production car. A production car has to carry all kinds of safety and emissions systems that racing cars don't, as well as sound-proofing and serviceability. I can't imagine what a PITA it would be to have to change the brakes and rotors on inboard brakes if they were on a production car. It would be great for performance, but the issues involved just make them too impractical.

As you'll note in automotive tire specs, they do have load ratings which is what the sidewalls can handle under proper inflation pressures. It's a combination of materials used, thickness and design profile. Tire rubber compound recipes are an arcane art which each company guards jealously. That determines grip and how the tire handles heat and wear, but the load strength is based on the tire profile and what's embedded inside the rubber.

I couldn't even begin to tell you how many hours I've spent researching tires and wheels over the years for the various cars I've owned. What I can tell you is the tires and wheels we have available today are better than anything we've ever had before.
 
1) Hmmm, somehow I got it in my head that only the tread is re-enforced, but I see from an online search that is incorrect.

One issue that can happen with high profile tires is rebound under-damping. In the extreme case, my backhoe has 4' tall tires with a 1' sidewall. These tires are the entire suspension of the vehicle, since I do not have the optional active suspension feature. The backhoe is unstable above about 15MPH because it bounces uncontrollably. I would not expect that kind of mis-behavior from a car (the backhoe also has CG and moment of inertia issues), but when you increase the profile of the tires of a car you are adding undamped springing.

My experience is that lower profile tires give the vehicle a more "direct" feel. Keep in mind than handling and cornering performance, although strongly correlated, are not the same thing. Handling == how easy it is to navigate turns at speed. Cornering performance == how fast a turn can be navigated regardless of the effort involved.

2) I think a bicycle tire has more loading per amount of material than a car tire. My bicycle tires have to be able to handle 100lbs of loading with no suspension (i.e. shock loads are significant) and with most of the load able to shift fore-aft substantially. They weigh 1/2 pound. Giulia's tires handle 15 times the weight, but weigh 50 times as much. The bicycle tire is not fiber re-enforced rubber but instead rubber sealed fibers; they are almost all fiber-a mix of Kevlar and Aramid fibers. Bicycle tires made a huge jump in performance about 15 years ago. They are much more expensive than car tires for the amount of material you get.

3) If you needed to tune the wheels on your Triumph from time to time the wheels were clearly not designed using the principals put forth by Jobst Brandt. I believe he published the 1st edition in the early 1980s. Rumor has it that he once was an engineer at Ferrari, but I know him as an HP employee. At HP he was able to get access to the computing power needed to do finite element analysis on a spoked bicycle wheel (difficult, circa 1980) and found that "common knowledge" about how a wire wheel works was 100% wrong. The major points that I remember are:
A) The spokes must be as tight as possible to get the maximum strength from the wheel. Spoke tension only decreases when the wheel is in use. This is the single biggest problem with most older wire spoked wheels.
B) The spokes are springs, so that thicker spokes do not make a stronger wheel.
C) The spokes should be straight except for an elbow at one end. The elbow should be thicker than the rest of the spoke.
D) The spokes must not be allowed to rotate while the nipples are turned or they will appear to loosen in use as they "untwist". The nipple threads should be slathered in anti-seize or it will not be possible to achieve A) or D). A special hardening anti-seize compound is best.
E) The spokes should be overtightened and then relaxed slightly. Brandt's method for doing this without breaking anything when building a bicycle wheel would not work for a car wheel.

A spoked steel and aluminum bicycle wheel is about 2/3rds of the weight of a full carbon fiber bicycle wheel of similar strength. Although the front wheel of a bicycle has the rim centered over the hub, the rear wheel has a substantial offset in order to make room for the gears on the hub.

Building a wire wheel properly is labor intensive, so maybe they got too expensive? Racers migrated away from them in the late 1950s, long before information about how to design and build them properly became available.

4) I can't tell from the picture. The wheel looks like it is installed "inside out" in the picture.
My Etype had inboard rear brakes. Changing the pads was not difficult. Changing the rotors involved tearing the whole back of the car apart. Heaven help you if the seals in the differential start leaking (as purchased, I could see daylight around the differential seals, plus the calipers were badly rusted inside-what a mess!). The Etype has removable panels in the trunk to ease access to the rear pads, but I found I could get at the pads from underneath reasonably easily. Etype rear brakes are notorious for overheating on the track; Jag even produced a track kit for reducing the problem.

Both wheels and tires have pressure and load ratings. On my pickup the wheels are rated 95psi max and 3500 pounds max, while the tires are rated 115psi max and 4650 pounds max. One has to use the lower figure. Axle ratings also need to be considered.

For bicycle tires, wider lowers the rolling resistance as does higher pressure. However, wider generally means a lower maximum pressure and wide high pressure tires ride very rough making it not as straightforward to choose as it sounds. It is unclear what works to minimize rolling resistance for car tires.

Yes, car, bicycle and motorcycle tires have improved a lot in recent times. In comparison medium and heavy duty truck tires have gotten cheaper but not much better.
 
Interesting discussion.
 
owns 2020 Alfa Romeo Giulia Ti Sport AWD
The best option is to add the Centerline exhaust and V2 intake from Eurocompulsion. It vastly improved performance.
 
I was fortunate to find a base sport in the show room.. paddle shifters, dark 5 hole wheels, sport facias, red calipers. I was originally looking for a Ti but the base sport in stock had the individual options I wanted.
 
21 - 29 of 29 Posts