I have Geico. I hit a deer on one occasion and had someone turn left in front of me on another and the insurance experience was positive both times.It's not allstate or Geico. I've heard bad things about both. I have no idea what to expect and I've never heard of the company, Selective Insurance. We'll see.
Thank goodness she had good policy coverage regardless of carrier. You need to have uninsured AND underinsured where I live (California).